Business and Commercial Litigation in Federal Courts is
unique in four respects: its extraordinary author team; its focus on business
and commercial litigation; its pervasive emphasis on the strategic issues and
options that determine success or failure; and its inclusion of federal practice
and procedure, substantive law, and litigation tactics and techniques, all in
one package.
This set is designed to fill a significant void in the legal
literature with a sophisticated work that captures the insights and expertise of
the finest litigators in the United States. By utilizing the talents of those
noted for their special skills in handling particular kinds of commercial
litigation as well as those noted litigators whose practice includes a variety
of commercial cases, Business and Commercial Litigation in Federal Courts
serves as a blueprint for effective litigation.
The Section of Litigation of the American Bar Association has
sponsored and inspired this publication. A select group of highly experienced
attorneys and judges was invited to author chapters. More than 700 volunteered.
As many as 122 offered to write a single chapter and 50-75 volunteered for many
of the others. This remarkable willingness to respond when called upon to help
reflects the affection and high esteem in which the Section is held by its
members.
This publication was written by distinguished federal judges
and the cream of the commercial litigation bar, the best lawyers practicing in
the federal courts of this nation. They come from all parts of the United States
and are diverse in their particular expertise; nevertheless, all were united in
their commitment to share with lawyers everywhere the secrets of their craft
that distinguish the truly outstanding members of our profession. As a result,
this publication is a goldmine of insights and advice about the dynamics of
commercial litigation and how to apply expert lawyering skills and techniques to
the specific case at hand to achieve client objectives. The size, scope, depth
and sophistication of the chapters attest to the generosity of these renowned
authors. Despite the press of business and other commitments, the 152 authors of
this set completed their chapters on schedule, enabling completion of this
monumental six volume, 7,000 page work within one year after the solicitation of
authors. The Section of Litigation and commercial litigators everywhere owe them
a debt of gratitude. We are grateful as well to their law firm, many of the
finest firms in the country, for the extensive support and resources they
provided. Thus, this work reflects the efforts and significant contributions of
many hundreds of talented lawyers and their staffs.
I particularly thank the federal judges who have graciously
shared their valuable time and have given us the invaluable perspective of the
bench. They include Judges Harold Baer, Jr., James G. Carr, Warren W. Eginton,
David Hittner, William C. Lee, M. Margaret McKeown, Solomon Oliver, Jr., Randall
R. Rader and Roger Vinson. I thank as well two particularly distinguished former
federal judges, Marvin E. Frankel and Federick B. Lacey.
The enthusiasm of the American Bar Association and of the
Section of Litigation for this project is reflected in the generous
participation of its leadership. Authors who are former Presidents of the
American Bar Association include N. Lee Cooper, John J. Curtin, Jr., and Robert
D. Raven. Authors who are former Chairs of the Section of Litigation include (in
addition to Messrs. Cooper and Curtin) Paul J. Bschorr, Benjamin R. Civiletti,
Barry F. McNeil, Robert N. Sayler and Barbara M.G. Lynn, the Section's
Chair-Elect. We are particularly pleased to have been joined in this venture by
those who have rendered distinguished public service to this country including
Warren Christopher and Benjamin R. Civiletti.
Business and Commercial Litigation in Federal Courts is
a unique contribution to legal literature. There are other books on federal
practice and procedure but no other publication focuses on business and
commercial litigation. Business litigation is typically more complex than other
kinds of litigation. It often involves technical, arcane subjects unfamiliar to
many lawyers and most certainly to jurors, complex issues and subtleties as well
as ramifications that may extend far beyond any particular lawsuit. It
frequently presents complex arrangements of parties and law firms, often in
different jurisdictions and requiring application of the law of additional
jurisdictions, voluminous documents, sometimes numbering into the millions,
large amounts of money and sometimes even the viability of major companies hang
in the balance. Furthermore, federal courts are not the place to learn as you
go, by trial and error. The magnitude of the cases in dispute causes judges and
clients alike to expect from all participants commensurate knowledge and skill.
Unlike many other forms of litigation, commercial litigation is largely at the
behest of corporate clients. Corporate America increasingly and justifiably
demands high quality, strategically focused and cost effective litigation from
the lawyers who do battle on its behalf. Business and Commercial Litigation
in Federal Courts can help meet these needs.
Practitioners have heretofore had to apply general principles
of law and practice to the special challenges of commercial litigation. Now
readers can be guided by a work that does not oversimplify but which
specifically and candidly confronts the opportunities, problems and pitfalls of
commercial litigation and supplies strategies and solutions. Authors were
continually challenged to share their insights into the issues and problems that
worried them most about their cases-that woke them up at night during trials.
This work is permeated with these innermost thoughts.
Although many commercial litigators specialize in particular
fields, many other commercial litigators handle cases in a variety of
substantive areas. Deft handling of diverse litigation requires mastery of
substantive law but also understanding of the application of litigation
strategies and techniques to those substantive areas. For that reason this
publication includes 28 chapters covering the kinds of business and commercial
litigation most commonly encountered in federal courts written by litigators
chosen to author those chapters because of their special expertise in those
fields. Each such chapter guides the reader step by step with a nuts and bolts
exposition on the law, procedure and practice in the field including delineation
and achievement of objectives; the first considerations in assessing a case and
how to proceed; the factors that would influence choice of strategy; steps to
advance or secure the positions of both plaintiff and defense; the information
necessary to planning trial or settlement strategy; characteristic problems and
their solutions; issues to raise with clients; and considerations regarding
discovery, motion practice, expert and lay witnesses, trial preparation, trials,
and other matters that are unique to the field of law under discussion.
Business and Commercial Litigation in Federal Courts is
a self-contained library with everything needed to handle a commercial case. It
was painstakingly designed to provide readers with rapid access to this wealth
of information. In addition to text on law, procedure and litigation strategies,
special features include procedural and practice checklists, checklists of
essential allegations and defenses, checklists of sources of proof of essential
allegations and defenses, cross references from checklists to text, litigation
forms and jury charges. The format makes the information equally accessible and
useful for the commercial litigator when he needs an immediate answer as when he
has the luxury of several hours to read and learn at leisure. Special finding
tools include tables of contents, as well as tables of sections, cases
(including the full citations of the 25,000 cases cited), statutes, rules, forms
and jury instructions. The forms and jury charges are also contained on computer
disks that accompany this set so that they may be easily adapted for particular
cases.
This publication is a joint endeavor of the Section of
Litigation and West Group. All royalties from this publication go to the Section
of Litigation.
Marilyn Minzer of the West Group deserves our special thanks
for her extraordinary efforts. She worked closely with me and with the authors
in every facet and stage of this project. Her commitment to excellence has been
a source of inspiration. It is no exaggeration to say that this worthwhile
project could not have been completed without her diligence, expertise and
guidance.
I feel privileged to have served as Editor-in-Chief of this
publication. In that role I reviewed and commented on the chapters of all of the
authors. Throughout I was impressed by the creativity of this magnificent team
of volunteer litigators and judges. Their accumulated wisdom made this an
educational experience for me far beyond what I could have hoped for. In the
best traditions of our profession, our authors have created a significant work
which will be a lasting credit to the Section of Litigation. I am grateful for
the opportunity to have participated.
By: ROBERT L. HAIG
June 1998